Computers have made music printing accessible to the masses, but they
tend to deliver mediocre typography. Apparently, programmers have
been doing a shoddy job on notation programs. To illustrate that, we
had an amateur user set a piece of music in one of the most popular
Computers have made music printing accessible to the masses, but they
tend to deliver mediocre typography. Apparently, programmers have
been doing a shoddy job on notation programs. To illustrate that, we
had an amateur user set a piece of music in one of the most popular
2003. It was made with all of the default settings. The music is from
the Sarabande of the 2nd Cello Suite by J. S. Bach.
2003. It was made with all of the default settings. The music is from
the Sarabande of the 2nd Cello Suite by J. S. Bach.
@sourceimage{finale-sarabande-full,,,.png}
@sourceimage{finale-sarabande-full,,,.png}
This example far surpasses the previous one when it comes to
formatting errors: there are serious errors in literally
@emph{every} measure. The errors come in all sizes: a big one is the
This example far surpasses the previous one when it comes to
formatting errors: there are serious errors in literally
@emph{every} measure. The errors come in all sizes: a big one is the
measure 13, which is covered by the note preceding it. Here is a
magnification of that measure:
@divClass{float-center}
measure 13, which is covered by the note preceding it. Here is a
magnification of that measure:
@divClass{float-center}
@sourceimage{finale-flat-detail,,,.png}
@sourceimage{finale-flat-detail,,,.png}
The errors go down to the teensy details: below is a blowup of the
beam in that measure. Of course, in proper typography the beam should
The errors go down to the teensy details: below is a blowup of the
beam in that measure. Of course, in proper typography the beam should
@sourceimage{finale-beam-detail,,,.png}
@sourceimage{finale-beam-detail,,,.png}
Now, one could refute that Finale has a graphical interface, and it
lets you easily move about elements to correct errors, or use plug-ins
Now, one could refute that Finale has a graphical interface, and it
lets you easily move about elements to correct errors, or use plug-ins
@sourceimage{finale-flat-correct,,,.png}
@sourceimage{finale-flat-correct,,,.png}
Unless you are an expert, typographical errors will irk you without
being obvious. Many of them will go uncorrected and will still be in the
Unless you are an expert, typographical errors will irk you without
being obvious. Many of them will go uncorrected and will still be in the
Next: @ref{problem-statement,How not to design software},
or: modeling music notation.
Next: @ref{problem-statement,How not to design software},
or: modeling music notation.